Braiding, pt. 1: The question

Since Electromagnetic Field 2014, I have been slowly making progress on a recreational math problem about braiding. In this blog post, I will show you the type of braid I am interested in and present the problem.

Making an (8,3) braid

To make what I will later refer to as an (8,3) braid, you will need:
First, cut an octagon from the cardboard. The easiest way to do this is to start with a rectangle, then cut its corners off.
Next, use the pencil to punch a hole in the middle of your octagon and cut a small slit in each face of the octagon.
Now, tie the ends of your wool together, and put them through the hole. pull each strand of wool into one of the slits.
Now you are ready to make a braid. Starting from the empty slit, count around to the third strand of will. Pull this out of its slit then into the empty slit. Then repeat this starting at the newly empty slit each time. After a short time, a braid should form through the hole in the cardboard.

The problem

I call the braid you have just made the (8,3) braid, as there are 8 slits and you move the 3rd strand each time. After I first made on of these braid, I began to wonder what was special about 8 and 3 to make this braid work, and for what other numbers \(a\) and \(b\) the (\(a\),\(b\)) would work.
In my next blog post, I will give two conditions on \(a\) and \(b\) that cause the braid to fail. Before you read that, I recommend having a go at the problem yourself. To help you on your way, I am compiling a list of braids that are known to work or fail at Good luck!

Similar posts

Electromagnetic Field talk
Braiding, pt. 2
Christmas cross stitch
Logical contradictions


Comments in green were written by me. Comments in blue were not written by me.
@no: yes, although rectangles work surprisingly well
Would square cardboard work better than a rectangle
 Add a Comment 

I will only use your email address to reply to your comment (if a reply is needed).

Allowed HTML tags: <br> <a> <small> <b> <i> <s> <sup> <sub> <u> <spoiler> <ul> <ol> <li>
To prove you are not a spam bot, please type "n" then "u" then "m" then "b" then "e" then "r" in the box below (case sensitive):


Show me a random blog post

May 2021

Close encounters of the second kind

Jan 2021

Christmas (2020) is over
▼ show ▼
▼ show ▼
▼ show ▼
▼ show ▼
▼ show ▼
▼ show ▼
▼ show ▼
▼ show ▼
▼ show ▼


raspberry pi weather station machine learning exponential growth sorting wave scattering rugby guest posts world cup noughts and crosses pi approximation day binary gaussian elimination accuracy mathsjam plastic ratio national lottery triangles mathsteroids dates curvature pi nine men's morris sport ucl matt parker stirling numbers bempp cambridge pizza cutting tmip inverse matrices captain scarlet misleading statistics signorini conditions palindromes stickers approximation data data visualisation puzzles latex phd royal baby numerical analysis mathslogicbot london underground game of life golden spiral draughts hannah fry interpolation asteroids arithmetic reddit games graph theory computational complexity ternary football frobel trigonometry chebyshev error bars radio 4 dragon curves estimation convergence dataset light bubble bobble wool python manchester coins programming news electromagnetic field matrix of cofactors braiding the aperiodical preconditioning people maths chalkdust magazine bodmas statistics books cross stitch final fantasy pac-man pascal's triangle chess craft recursion christmas simultaneous equations sound gerry anderson folding tube maps geometry graphs map projections matrix multiplication folding paper hexapawn weak imposition rhombicuboctahedron harriss spiral hats a gamut of games realhats big internet math-off javascript pythagoras matrix of minors geogebra sobolev spaces video games talking maths in public go game show probability tennis polynomials platonic solids determinants menace numbers logic speed php fractals countdown inline code oeis boundary element methods london matrices twitter royal institution flexagons squares christmas card reuleaux polygons finite element method european cup advent calendar manchester science festival martin gardner propositional calculus golden ratio quadrilaterals probability logs


Show me a random blog post
▼ show ▼
© Matthew Scroggs 2012–2021